Cardinal Pizza Shop

We ordered takeout, and both the pizza and the buffalo chicken wrap were very good! The service was quick.

This was my first visit here. It's a small place with great NY-style pizza. Our order: Margarita pizza was the best we had in Ohio. I'll be definitely back soon. I highly recommend this establishment. And thank you for the "Nextdoor" app and neighbors recommendation...

Best meatball subs in town!! The pizza sauce and crust is great as well. Prices are pretty good for the quality

YUM YUM YUM!!!! Found this place one afternoon and ordered carry out. We got a small order of medium wings which came with six (good sized wings) and were really tasty, a medium bbq chicken pizza that we loved and the buffalo chicken dip appetizer which was the best buffalo chicken dip I've had in a long time and came with chips. This will now we our regular spot! Inside was a small but loved the cozy atmosphere and there is lots of public parking around. Employees were so kind. Prices were so reasonable and the prices were more than fair!!! Couldn't recommend more!!!!

Cool hidden spot in uptown. Small 8-10 seat bar. Very nice bartender. Order some carryout propapie was amazing, great NY crust and awesome pepperoni Wings were plump and juicy!

This is my favorite pizza shop in Columbus. Why? First I love the vibe. Its a small shop and I mean right now its small and truly, I love that. However, its in the process of acquiring/modifying the space next door so it will get bigger. Im sure I will still love bigger as it eill be easier to get seating. Currently it has four tables and a bar that seats 7-8. Everything is made in house except the cauliflower crust, boneless chicken and one other thing, which I dont get, so I forgot what it is. The salads are great. The dressings are made in-house, their ranch is my favorite. The bar is fun to sit at and very comfortable. they hire great people that are always fun to talk to. They have two types of crust: NY Style and Columbus style. Both are good but I prefer the NY style. They have two sauces, spicy and regular. The spicy is amazing. The regular is sweeter than the spicy (imo) My go to here is the NY style Taylors favorite.. omit sausage on half and "a Propa-Pie, add sausage to entire pie. The pepperoni is the type that curls upward and their sausage is good sized. The mushrooms are so fresh. Yum. Thanks Mel (one of the owners) for always making us feel like regulars even tho we come in sporadically and always sending us home happy and full!

Ended up going here to grab a pizza for the Browns vs Cardinals game. Ironic, isn't it? But, unlike the Cardinals football team, this pizza is not slouch. When we pulled up, I noticed that they were Browns supporters, so I knew I was in for a treat. The cashier was very welcoming and friendly. We ordered the Proper Pie to go, and this pizza featured Old World Pepperoni, which is my favorite! The pizza looked and smelled phenomenal when we got into the car. My wife was not in the mood for pizza, so she ordered one of their meatball subs. When we got home, we dug in. The pizza had a thinner crust, and the flavors were amazing. The pepp was cripsy and bold! The cheese had a nice pull, and the sauce was very complimentary. I drizzled a little ranch on a slice, and it enhanced the pie even more. The crust had a nice crunch to it as well. My wife said that she enjoyed her meatball sub and the slice of pie she tried. I would give this place another go, and I would like to try another one of their specialty pizzas. The Proper Pie Pizza 1-5=4.5! Customer Service 1-5=5!

First impression visit. Good pizza. Ample public parking. Convenient texting when carryout is ready. 5 dine in tables with an expansion in the future. 10 seat bar with limited selection, but yet plenty of desirable choices. Fair prices. Quality ingredients and recipe. Red sauce is semi sweet. Crust is ok without the crackery flaking, and more of a chewy texture. #UpCloseSavor

Friends recommended trying this pizza. I can honestly say it's the best in Westerville. I ordered a build your own 14 inch NY style with pepperoni, pineapple, and red onions... yes I put pineapple on 1/2 the pizza. I do appreciate that they use real pineapple. I ordered online and liked that they texted you when it was ready. The girl working was super friendly. Its a small place. I give the pizza a solid 4/5. I would come back and order the pizza. I do wish they offered bigger sizes. As for the small salad... a total scam! 12 pieces of spinach for $5.25... Don't make the same mistake I did. :(